Common Mistakes That Damage The Customer Experience & How to Avoid Them

Customer Experience mistakes cost more than you think, literally.

According to PwC, 1 in 3 customers will walk away from a brand they love after just one bad experience. And our own 2025 Professional Services Client Journey Report found that over 70% of prospects who make an initial enquiry never hear back from the business at all. That’s not just a service failure; that’s revenue lost before a relationship even starts.

Whether you’re in professional services, hospitality, retail, or beyond, small Customer Experience (CX) mistakes often go unnoticed internally but leave a significant impact on customer loyalty, reputation, and revenue. The good news? Most are fixable, once you spot them.

Let’s explore the most common customer experience mistakes, with real examples and practical ways to avoid them.

Table of Contents

• Mistake #1 – Not Understanding the Customer Journey
• Mistake #2 – Ignoring Customer Feedback
• Mistake #3 – Inconsistent Service Across Touchpoints
• Mistake #4 – Overlooking Employee Engagement
• Mistake #5 – Making the Enquiry Process Difficult
• Mistake #6 – Failing to Personalise the Experience
• How to Audit and Improve Your CX
• Turn Mistakes Into Momentum

Mistake #1 – Not Understanding the Customer Journey

You can’t fix what you can’t see.

A common mistake businesses make is failing to map the whole customer journey, from the first click or call to long-term engagement. Without this, internal teams often don’t realise where drop-offs, frustration, or inconsistency occur.

From gaps between marketing and operations to mixed messages at different touchpoints, these customer journey mapping mistakes lead to a disjointed experience that damages trust.

Please read our guide to the Retail Customer Journey to see how journey mapping applies across sectors.

Need to map your journey? Learn more about our Customer Journey Mapping service.

Mistake #2 – Ignoring Customer Feedback

Collecting feedback and then ignoring it? That’s worse than not asking at all.

Whether it’s surveys, reviews, or one-to-one feedback, customers notice when their voices are heard, and when they’re not. Without a clear customer feedback strategy, insights gather dust and frustrations build.

Using tools like instant insight, you can act on feedback in real time, close the loop with customers, and empower your team to make smart, responsive changes.

Explore our blog on Customer Feedback for practical tips that drive loyalty.

Mistake #3 – Inconsistent Service Across Touchpoints

Imagine getting excellent service over the phone, but poor treatment in person. Or walking into one location and being treated differently at another. Customers don’t separate their experiences by channel or department; they see one brand.

An inconsistent Customer Experience causes confusion, erodes trust, and leads to bad reviews. Whether it’s tone of voice, response time, or brand presentation, consistency is key.

Our blog on Customer Experience vs. Customer Service breaks this down further.

Find out how our CX and Service training programmes help unify standards across your team.

Mistake #4 – Overlooking Employee Engagement

There’s no great Customer Experience (CX) without a great Employee Experience (EX).

Engaged, motivated teams are more likely to deliver exceptional service. Yet many organisations focus on front-facing Customer Experience strategies without addressing internal culture, communication, or support.

Studies show that companies with highly engaged employees outperform those without by up to 202% (Gallup). And we’ve seen it firsthand—look at our Bluestone case study for proof.

Please read our blogs on the ROI of Employee Well-being and the Cost of a Bad Employee Experience.

Discover how our Training & Development services help create engaged teams that deliver better CX.

Mistake #5 – Making the Enquiry Process Difficult

Our 2025 Professional Services Client Journey Report revealed that many businesses fail to respond to enquiries within 48 hours, if at all. The result? Professional services firms lose millions yearly due to poor enquiry handling.

Slow replies, unclear forms, or generic responses frustrate potential customers and often send them to competitors. A smooth, timely, and personalised enquiry handling process can be the difference between a lead lost and a customer gained.

See how The Family Law Company turned enquiry handling into a CX strength in our case study.

Please read our blog on the Enquiry Handling Process for more.

Mistake #6 – Failing to Personalise the Experience

Customers don’t want to feel like a number.

A generic, one-size-fits-all approach can make even well-intentioned service feel cold. Whether it’s using a customer’s name, remembering their preferences, or tailoring your message, personalisation builds loyalty.

And the data backs it up: McKinsey found that personalisation can drive up to 15% revenue growth and increase marketing efficiency by 30%.

Please read our blog on Why Personalised Customer Experience Matters for simple tips that make a big difference.

How to Audit and Improve Your CX

If any of the above mistakes sound familiar, it’s time for a review.

Start by auditing key areas of your customer journey:

• Are touchpoints consistent?
• Are enquiries responded to quickly and personally?
• Are you gathering and acting on customer feedback?
• Is your team empowered and engaged?

While internal reviews are valuable, having unbiased, expert insight can reveal blind spots that might otherwise go unnoticed. That’s why working with an independent Customer Experience (CX) specialist makes all the difference.

At insight6, our local CX Directors combine deep regional knowledge with national expertise. They work closely with you to identify what’s working, what’s not, and how to move forward with a clear, measurable strategy.

Find your local CX Director today and start turning feedback into growth.

Or learn more about our Customer Experience Solutions.

Turn Mistakes Into Momentum

Every business makes mistakes—but the best ones learn from them, act quickly, and keep improving.

Customer expectations are higher than ever, but so are the tools and insights available to meet them. Whether it’s journey mapping, real-time feedback, or team training, there are proven ways to improve customer experience and grow your business.

Are you ready to fix the customer experience mistakes costing you loyalty and revenue? Contact us today.

At insight6, we work with over 1,200 businesses, offering tailored solutions to transform CX from end to end. To connect with your local CX Specialist, call +44 (0)800 970 8987 or visit www.insight6.com

Sign up for the insight6 newsletter to stay ahead with the latest CX strategies and insights.